Natural Carmine
Cochineal Lake
This famous red is made of crushed insects, and it seems like it's everywhere-- from food to cosmetics, and yes, even in paint.
The art history term Red Lake can mean a lot of different things, and of the them could be Cochineal. There are different species of insect that are used to make the color referred to as Carmine, and they have different pigment codes.
Artiscreation defines Cochineal NR4 as, "Laked extract from dried bodies of the female cochineal insect (Coccus cacti)." Cochineal insects live on a particular kind of cactus and were of major interest as an export from the Americas as a red dye that was a stronger colorant than Kermes.
In the discussion of textile dyes, the definitions and requirements for lightfastness differ than those required for archival artist's pigments. Some sources describe Cochineal as lightfast, but for painting purposes, we wish it were more lightfast.
Sasha Duerr's book on Natural Palettes notes that when used as a dye, "because cochineal is pH sensitive, it can provide a wide range of hot pinks, fuchsias, and reds as well as purples, blues, and dark grays, depending on how the color is modified."
While some have described this red as nontoxic, Monona Rossol mentions that many anthraquinone-related pigments have not been properly tested and may pose a risk. She specifically lists "Natural Red 4 (from cochineal-producing insects)" as one which has not been sufficiently tested.
Also check out NR3 for a discussion of the other crimson insect, Kermes.
NR4 pigment data from David G. Myers, The Color of Art Pigment Database, Artiscreation.com
Information about NR4 from Bruce MacEvoy, Handprint Guide to Watercolors
CAMEO Materials Database: Conservation & Art Materials Encyclopedia Online, Museum of Fine Arts Boston. (Accessed February 2026). Cochineal. Museum of Fine Arts Boston.
CAMEO Materials Database: Conservation & Art Materials Encyclopedia Online, Museum of Fine Arts Boston. (Accessed February 2026). [Kermes](https://cameo.mfa.org/wiki/Kermeshttps://cameo.mfa.org/wiki/Kermes. Museum of Fine Arts Boston
Rossol, Monona. The Artist's Complete Health and Safety Guide. New York, NY : Allworth Press, 2001. The book is rather dated, updated information is available from her website
Duerr, Sasha. Natural Palettes: Inspiration from Plant-Based Color. Princeton Architectural Press, New York, 2020. https://amzn.to/4bRE2Le
Previously thought to be Lower Concern, may be a hazard, due to similarity with carcinogenic anthraquinones
Monona Rossol describes this as “carminic acid from coccus cacti insect. Carmine if laked with aluminum or calcium. An anthraquinone.” Though specific toxicity data is lacking, it is related to the cancer-causing Anthraquinones.
Medium to high
Varies from medium-high to high by volume
DISCLAIMER: Please note that we are not experts in health and safety and we are not toxicologists, please consult the proper experts. We are not liable for any issues that may arise from the use of our website or its contents. The information contained in this site is provided without warranty or guarantee of any kind. We do not necessarily endorse any other website that are linked from our site. For any important pigment specs, please reference the manufacturer details. If you discover errors or omissions, please reach out through our contact form. Thank you.
